Four Suspects Arrested in Connection with the Fatal Shooting of 17-Year-Old KayLee Dutton

The Cedar City community has been left in shock following the tragic shooting death of 17-year-old KayLee Dutton. Law enforcement officials have announced the arrest of four suspects believed to be involved in the incident, marking a significant step in the pursuit of justice.

The Incident: A Fatal Pursuit Near Cedar City

On January 17, 2025, at approximately 10:42 p.m., a red pickup truck carrying two teenage girls was pursued by another vehicle flashing its high beams. The pursuit started on Lund Highway, continued west along Midvalley Road, and ended near the intersection of 4300 West, close to the Three Peaks Recreation Area.

Arrest of Two Teens in Connection with the Tragic Death of Ka’Niyah Baker

Iron County Sheriff Ken Carpenter described the tragic moment when the suspect vehicle pulled alongside the red pickup and opened fire. “Several rounds were shot into the driver’s side of the vehicle, ultimately killing the driver,” he stated. KayLee, who was driving, succumbed to her injuries shortly after being transported to Cedar City Hospital. Her passenger, who sustained a leg injury, remains under observation.

The Arrests: Swift Action by Law Enforcement

Within 24 hours of the fatal shooting, Iron County Metro SWAT officers executed a search warrant at a townhome complex west of Lund Highway. Three suspects were apprehended during the operation, and a fourth was arrested later that day at his workplace. Sheriff Carpenter expressed confidence in the arrests, stating, “We feel pretty good we have our suspects.”

The suspects include:

  • Ethan Galloway and Michael Hess-Witucki, both charged with second-degree felony murder, 12 counts of felony discharge of a firearm, marijuana possession, and possession of a dangerous weapon by a restricted person.
  • Matthew Sorber-Petrie and Aldric Felipe, both charged with obstructing justice, marijuana possession, and weapon possession.

The Investigation: Piecing Together the Evidence

Investigators have been meticulously collecting and processing evidence from the crime scene and surrounding areas. Iron County search and rescue teams, using metal detectors and search dogs, recovered at least one .223 caliber shell casing linked to the shooting.

Sheriff Carpenter emphasized the thoroughness of the investigation, stating, “We need to process the apartment, the vehicle, and conduct detailed interviews.” Authorities are also pursuing multiple leads to ensure no detail is overlooked.

Community Grieves the Loss of KayLee Dutton

While law enforcement has not officially released the victim’s name, social media tributes and crowdfunding campaigns have identified her as 17-year-old KayLee Dutton. Known for her kind and vibrant spirit, KayLee’s death has deeply affected her family, friends, and the Cedar City community.

Memorials and vigils have been held in her honor, with a crowdfunding campaign launched to support her family during this difficult time. Community members describe her as a bright young soul taken too soon.

Legal Proceedings and the Road to Justice

As of January 19, formal charges had not yet been filed in the 5th District Court. Sheriff Carpenter remains committed to holding the suspects accountable. “I’m confident that we will bring the perpetrators of this crime to justice,” he said.

The passenger of the red pickup has not yet given a formal statement as she recovers from the trauma. Authorities have decided to delay her interview to ensure a clear and accurate account of the events.

Addressing Gun Violence: A Call for Change

The tragic loss of KayLee Dutton has reignited discussions about gun violence and public safety in Iron County. Residents and community leaders are calling for stronger preventative measures to address the root causes of such crimes.

“This senseless violence is a stark reminder of the importance of community action,” said a local advocate. “We must work together to create a safer environment for our children.”

Conclusion: Honoring KayLee Dutton’s Legacy

The arrests in connection with KayLee Dutton’s death mark a significant step toward justice. However, her untimely death serves as a sobering reminder of the devastating impact of violence.

The Cedar City community remains united in grief and determination, vowing to honor KayLee’s memory by fostering a safer future and ensuring justice is served. As investigations continue, her story stands as a powerful call to action to address the root causes of violence and protect future generations.

Leave a Comment