A tragic shooting on March 30, 2025, at the Portside Pub in Hammond, Indiana, has left the community in shock and mourning. The incident claimed the lives of two victims, bartender Paul and 32-year-old Lorraine Reyna, and injured three others. Authorities have arrested Caprice Edward Cashaw, 34, in connection with the shooting. Cashaw is facing multiple charges, including manslaughter, criminally negligent homicide, reckless driving, and operating a vehicle with a suspended license.
Connor Russell Death & Obituary: Utah Mourns the Loss of a Beloved Son, Brother, and Friend
The Incident
The shooting occurred just before 4 a.m. on March 30, 2025. Hammond Police responded to reports of gunfire at the Portside Pub, a popular nightlife venue. Upon arrival, they found five individuals with gunshot wounds. Tragically, Paul, the bartender on duty, and Lorraine Reyna were pronounced dead at the scene. The remaining three victims were taken to local hospitals, with two in serious condition and one in stable condition.
The Victims
Paul, 48, had been working as a bartender at Portside Pub for over five years. He was beloved by his coworkers and the regular patrons, who described him as the heart and soul of the pub. “Paul was always there for everyone. He was more than just a bartender—he was a friend to us all,” said one of his colleagues.
Lorraine Reyna, a 32-year-old mother, was described as a kind-hearted woman who always helped others. Her family expressed deep sorrow over her passing, remembering her as someone who made everyone feel welcome, whether they were a stranger or a lifelong friend. Lorraine had been visiting friends at the pub that night, unaware that it would be her last.
Caprice Edward Cashaw: A Troubling History
Caprice Cashaw, the man arrested in connection with the shooting, has a criminal history. In 2022, he was involved in an incident at an East Chicago casino where he allegedly tried to run over an Indiana Gaming Commission agent in a parking lot. Despite the severity of the incident, Cashaw was charged with criminal recklessness rather than attempted murder. His case was delayed several times, and he was not incarcerated, leading some to question why he was allowed to remain free.
“This is a tragic situation—one that could have been prevented,” said a law enforcement official. Concerns have grown about the delays in legal proceedings and the failure to keep repeat offenders off the streets.
Investigation and Motive
Investigators are still working to understand the full circumstances of the shooting. Early evidence suggests that the incident may have been related to a personal dispute. Hammond Police are asking the public for assistance and have set up a hotline for anyone with relevant information.
“We’re looking into all aspects of the case, but early evidence suggests that the shooting could have been sparked by a domestic-related altercation,” said Detective Lt. Marc Ferry of the Hammond Police Department.
Community Response and Advocacy
The community of Hammond is devastated by the violence, with many residents expressing disbelief that such an event could occur in their tight-knit town. Local advocacy groups are calling for better support for victims of domestic violence and stronger intervention programs to prevent such situations from escalating to deadly violence.
“This kind of violence is preventable,” said Sheila Martinez, the director of a local women’s shelter. “We need more resources and better systems in place to support victims of domestic abuse.”
A Call for Justice
As the investigation unfolds, residents of Hammond are hoping for justice for the victims. A memorial service is being planned for Paul, Lorraine, and the other victims who were injured in the shooting. The Portside Pub remains closed as authorities continue their investigation.
For Caprice Cashaw, the legal consequences of his actions are still being determined. With multiple serious charges pending, the path forward for both the victims’ families and the community of Hammond will be one of reflection, healing, and a renewed focus on preventing violence in the future.
As the legal proceedings continue, the community remains hopeful that justice will prevail and that such a tragic event will not happen again.
