After 31 years of mystery and heartache, the identity of “Baby Hope,” a newborn found murdered in Franklin, Indiana in 1994, has finally been revealed. Thanks to advances in DNA technology and genetic genealogy, law enforcement has confirmed the identities of her biological parents, bringing long-awaited answers to a case that haunted the community for decades.
Lamont Green Obituary: Former Football Star and Dedicated Coach Dies at 49By BobJuly 16, 2025
What Happened to Baby Hope in 1994?
On April 13, 1994, two boys playing in Temple Park in Franklin, Indiana made a horrifying discovery: the body of a newborn baby girl inside a trash can. Authorities determined the child had died from multiple stab wounds. The Johnson County Coroner ruled it a homicide.
Despite years of investigation, the case remained unsolved. The infant, lovingly named “Baby Hope” by the community, was given a proper burial in Greenlawn Cemetery. Donations covered her headstone, and her memory lived on in the hearts of Franklin residents.
Breakthrough in the Case: DNA and Public Databases
Investigators preserved Baby Hope’s DNA in hopes that one day, technological advancements would shed light on her origins. That day came in 2019, when the case was reopened and genealogical DNA techniques were applied.
Using DNA from public genealogy databases, detectives traced familial connections, eventually identifying Baby Hope’s biological parents. This breakthrough marked a major milestone in the cold case.
Who Were Baby Hope’s Biological Parents?
Through detailed genetic research, investigators identified Baby Hope’s mother as Cheryl D. Larsen, who passed away in 2018. The father, Paul R. Shepherd, was initially unaware he had a daughter. He voluntarily submitted his DNA, which confirmed his paternity.
Shepherd, shocked and heartbroken by the revelation, expressed his grief in a statement. He emphasized his lack of knowledge regarding Larsen’s pregnancy and birth, and he fully cooperated with the investigation.
In a tribute to the daughter he never knew, Shepherd officially named the child Hope Shepherd, retiring the anonymous label “Baby Hope” after three long decades.
Ongoing Investigation and Unanswered Questions
While the identity of Baby Hope’s parents is now known, several aspects of the case remain unresolved. Investigators have not determined who was responsible for the baby’s death. Cheryl Larsen, the baby’s mother, cannot be questioned, having died years prior.
Franklin Police Chief Kirby Cochran and Johnson County Coroner Mike Pruitt have confirmed that the case remains open. They urged the public to come forward with any additional information that could help solve the remaining pieces of the mystery.
Despite the powerful role of DNA in cracking the case, investigators acknowledge that genetic evidence alone cannot explain everything.
Community Reaction: A Mix of Closure and Pain
The Franklin community, which has grieved for Baby Hope since 1994, has expressed both relief and sorrow. Residents praised the persistence of law enforcement and the power of forensic science in resolving the child’s identity.
For Paul Shepherd and his family, the discovery has taken an emotional toll. In his statement, he asked for privacy as they continue to process the tragedy and its painful implications.
Conclusion: A Name Restored, But the Story Continues
The revelation of Baby Hope’s true identity brings a long-awaited sense of closure to a decades-old mystery. However, the search for justice continues. Investigators remain committed to uncovering the full truth behind her death.
As Franklin mourns anew and honors Hope Shepherd by name, her story remains a solemn reminder of resilience, justice, and the powerful bond of community.
This story is still developing. Further updates will be provided as new information emerges.